Why agencies give different magnitudes
Updated 2026-11-19
Open almost any event page here and you’ll see a small table: one earthquake, several magnitudes. That isn’t a bug. It’s how seismology works, and we show it on purpose.
A real example
In 2026 an earthquake struck the Texas Panhandle, 38 km SSE of Spearman. TexNet, the Texas network, reported 5.0 as a local magnitude (ML). The USGS national center reported 4.4 as a regional moment magnitude (Mwr). Same earthquake, a 0.6 gap.
Why it happens
Each magnitude type reads a different part of the seismic signal. USGS lists the main ones:
- ML, local magnitude: the original Richter-style scale, mostly used for small, nearby quakes.
- Md, duration magnitude: based on how long the shaking signal lasts, for small events.
- mb, body-wave magnitude: from P waves. USGS says it tends to saturate around M6.5 — bigger quakes stop looking bigger to it.
- Ms, surface-wave magnitude: saturates around M8.3.
- Mw and its variants (Mww, Mwc, Mwb, Mwr): moment magnitude, tied to the size of the fault slip itself. For larger quakes, USGS treats Mww as the authoritative value when it’s computed; Mwr is authoritative below M5.0.
Then there are the stations. Two networks using the same method but different seismometers will land on slightly different numbers.
Big historical quakes show it too. USGS lists three magnitudes for 1906 San Francisco: 7.7 (surface-wave), 7.9 (moment), and the traditional 8¼ from Richter’s era. It prefers the moment magnitude.
How to read our table
The row marked used by USGS is the solution USGS currently treats as preferred for the event summary. Other rows come from the regional networks that also solved the event, plus EMSC (the European-Mediterranean Seismological Centre) as an outside second opinion for magnitude 4+ events. We drop solutions from the US early-warning system on purpose; this site doesn’t use that data.
The sentence under the table is written by a small rule, from the numbers in the table and nothing else: if the spread is 0.2 or less, we call it normal scatter; if it’s bigger, we say which methods differ.
Sources
- USGS — Magnitude types
- USGS — 1906 San Francisco earthquake, magnitude
- USGS event tx2026ojlaky (Texas, 2026)
- EMSC-CSEM SeismicPortal
QuakeWhere is an independent site, not affiliated with USGS. More explainers · Live map